Существуют ли другие записи сонат на CD, кроме указанных в каталоге Танина:
Piano Sonata No.3 in E, D.459
Piano Sonata No.6 in e, D.566
Piano Sonata No.11 in f, D.625
Piano Sonata No.14 in a, D.784, Op.143
Piano Sonata No.16 in a, D.845, Op.42
Дело в том, что на всех известных мне лейблах звукозаписи, эти сонаты, почему то, записаны практически одинаково. Ну например - №9 и №11 или №15 и №16 или №19 и №21.
Не хотелось бы покупать СD только из за одного произведения, ведь второе есть.
Думаю, подобные вопросы актуальны не только для меня (учитыва стоимость фирменных дисков).
Сонаты Шуберта
-
- Сообщения: 149
- Зарегистрирован: Вс мар 20, 2011 3:22 pm
Re: Сонаты Шуберта
А что, соната №3 уже издана?penderecki писал(а):Существуют ли другие записи сонат на CD, кроме указанных в каталоге Танина:
Piano Sonata No.3 in E, D.459
........................................
Re: Сонаты Шуберта
Да, и уже давно. DOREMI DHR-7940/1 (2CD) Vol. 15M.I. писал(а):А что, соната №3 уже издана?
http://doremi.com/richter.html
Re: Сонаты Шуберта
Я всегда с недоверием относился к исполнению Бренделем многих произведений, особенно, сонат Шуберта. Вот подтверждение, объясняющее многое.
Not long ago Alfred Brendel gave a lecture on Schubert's last sonatas in Museum Louisiana in Danmark close to where I live. Afterwards I thanked him for his "performance" and since there were just the two of us, I could not resist asking what he thought of Sviatoslav Richter's performances of Schubert's sonatas and the the last one in particular, D.960.
"Do you like them?", he asked me, if one actually could like it. "Yes, actually I do", I replied, feeling a strange tension coming up. "That has nothing to do Schubert! , was his ferocious reply.
Then he started talking about the slow tempo of D.960, which is "Molto Moderato" and you can explain in different ways. No chance for me to reply, because he was ready to shake my hand to say goodbye.
I esteem Mr. Brendel very highly but was rather shocked by his comment. For me Richter's performances of Schubert are still treasures, no matter the tempo, and I am sure they will be for a long time to come.
http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/sv ... sage/10959
Not long ago Alfred Brendel gave a lecture on Schubert's last sonatas in Museum Louisiana in Danmark close to where I live. Afterwards I thanked him for his "performance" and since there were just the two of us, I could not resist asking what he thought of Sviatoslav Richter's performances of Schubert's sonatas and the the last one in particular, D.960.
"Do you like them?", he asked me, if one actually could like it. "Yes, actually I do", I replied, feeling a strange tension coming up. "That has nothing to do Schubert! , was his ferocious reply.
Then he started talking about the slow tempo of D.960, which is "Molto Moderato" and you can explain in different ways. No chance for me to reply, because he was ready to shake my hand to say goodbye.
I esteem Mr. Brendel very highly but was rather shocked by his comment. For me Richter's performances of Schubert are still treasures, no matter the tempo, and I am sure they will be for a long time to come.
http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/sv ... sage/10959
Он имел одно виденье,
Непостижное уму,
И глубоко впечатленье
В сердце врезалось ему.
(А.С.Пушкин)
Непостижное уму,
И глубоко впечатленье
В сердце врезалось ему.
(А.С.Пушкин)